Is Your Enterprise Architecture Practice in Chaos?
Enterprise architecture (EA) is meant to drive strategic alignment, streamline decision-making, and enable effective change. But without clear goals, standardized processes, and consistent oversight, it can easily become just another layer of useless bureaucracy. This often leads to an overwhelming amount of documentation that nobody reads, fragmented initiatives, and frustrated teams.
One of the biggest challenges is that the complexity of EA work can spiral out of control without anyone realizing it. Models and frameworks are added haphazardly without anyone seeing the big picture, and architecture governance becomes an endless cycle of approvals and revisions. Before you know it, architects are buried in work, and stakeholders are left confused and disengaged.
The question then becomes: how do you know if your EA practice delivers value or just creates more work?
The answer lies in assessing the maturity of your EA practice. Maturity is about more than just documentation or compliance—it is about how well the EA practice is managed an integrated within your organization. Manageability is the starting point for any effective organizational function.
And that is where maturity models and maturity assessments come in.
Why Maturity Models Matter
Maturity in EA describes how systematically and effectively EA practices are managed within an organization. It reveals whether there are clear goals, documented practices, measurement and follow-up, and continuous improvement mechanisms in place. Simply put, it shows whether EA is driving real value or just adding overhead.
Maturity models offer more than just theoretical guidance—they give you a structured approach to evaluate whether your EA activities are systematically managed or merely ad hoc, and whether all crucial areas and practices for a mature EA function are being effectively addressed.
The concept of maturity models originates from the Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI) framework, developed by Carnegie Mellon University. CMMI was initially designed to assess and improve software development processes, but its structured approach to process maturity has since been adapted to a wide range of domains, including EA.
Using a maturity model, you can evaluate your EA practice across critical dimensions, including strategic alignment, stakeholder engagement, resource utilization, and organizational integration.
With a maturity assessment, you gain:
A clear snapshot of your current EA state.
Actionable insights on how to improve governance, deliverables, processes, tools, and stakeholder engagement.
A roadmap for growth, helping you prioritize improvements that align with business goals.
What Do Maturity Models Measure?
Maturity models assess several key aspects of EA practices, offering a comprehensive overview of how well EA is managed, integrated, and utilized. Different models emphasize different areas, but generally, a maturity assessment should evaluate at least the following:
Objectives and Scope: Evaluates what EA means in the organization and whether the scope and objectives are clearly defined and aligned with strategic goals.
Commitment and Sponsorship: Measures the level of awareness, acceptance, and support for EA, especially from leadership.
Integration and Utilization: Assesses how well EA is integrated into other organizational functions and how effectively it is utilized.
Architecture Content: Evaluates the types and quality of EA content, including models, diagrams, and other documentation, as well as whether a standardized modeling approach is consistently followed.
Resources: Assesses the availability and adequacy of architectural resources, including the number of architects and their roles.
Skills and Competencies: Measures the level of architectural skills within the team and how actively these skills are developed.
Methods and Practices: Examines the frameworks, methods, and processes used in EA work.
Tools: Evaluates the tools and other technologies used to support EA activities.
Architecture in Development Initiatives: Assesses how architectural work is incorporated into development projects and continuous development activities.
Maturity Levels Explained
Maturity models typically classify the development of EA practices into levels:
No Development: No evidence of EA practices or their management.
Initial (Ad hoc): Unpredictable and reactive. EA activities are chaotic, and success depends on individual effort.
Developing: Basic activities are established and can be repeated, but are often reactive and inconsistent.
Defined: Activities are documented, standardized, and integrated into a unified system.
Managed and Measured: Activities are followed, measured, and controlled with data-driven decision-making.
Optimizing: Continuous improvement is pursued through feedback and innovation.
These levels provide a structured way to assess and improve EA practices over time, ensuring consistent progress toward goals.
How to Get Started?
Start by clarifying what EA means in your organization. What are its goals? Who are the key stakeholders? What are the most critical processes and deliverables? This helps set the scope for the maturity assessment.
Then, choose a suitable maturity model. There are many options available, each with its own strengths and focus areas. These range from consulting firm and tool vendor models to public sector-specific frameworks and custom in-house solutions. Select one that matches your organization’s needs and is easy to implement. It is crucial to stick with the same model over time for consistent progress tracking.
Finally, conduct the assessment. If you have a good understanding of your organization’s EA practices and can remain objective, you can perform the assessment internally. Interviewing key stakeholders can provide valuable insights. Alternatively, if you prefer an unbiased perspective or need expertise in a specific maturity model, hiring a consultant is a good option.
Ready to Find Out Where You Stand?
An EA maturity assessment is more than just ticking boxes—it is about gaining a clear understanding of where your EA practice is today and where it needs to go. It helps you focus on what truly matters, maximize the value of your EA resources, and drive meaningful change in your organization.
Take the next step and assess the maturity of your EA practice today. If you are unsure which maturity model to use, consider trying one from my former employer, Coala. I contributed to its development, and it is a short, user-friendly questionnaire available in English: Coala EA Maturity Questionnaire.
What is your experience with EA maturity assessments? Let’s discuss in the comments!
📚✨ Subscribe for more insights on making EA practical and impactful!